With property prices
reputed to have fallen throughout Italy
(on average, a price reduction of -18% in Florence and Turin
and -16% in Rome, followed by similar
reductions throughout Italy) and
corresponding reductions in the rental
market, the Italian Government has
launched a raft of legislation aimed at
protecting property owners in Italy from
the worst ravages of the credit crunch.
One of the main
provisions is effectively a “safety net”
which caps to 4% the interest payable on
variable rate mortgages used to finance
the purchase or restoration of the main,
residential home in Italy. Any interest
in excess of this rate is effectively
paid by the State, with a corresponding
tax credit to the Italian banks which
are called to implement this new
measure.
1)
The 4% rate cap on
mortgages - who may benefit.
The legislation
passed at the end of January 2009 in its
final form applies to anyone who has
taken a “variable rate mortgage” (Mutui
a tasso variabile) to finance the
purchase or restoration of the “main
residence” (Abitazione principale)
in Italy, with limited exceptions for
luxury properties, before 31.10.2008.
This benefit applies to individuals only
and not to companies.
Secondary regulations
currently being drafted will provide
further guidance on the meaning of
“variable rate mortgage”, given the
great variety of different types of
mortgage, currently available.
2)
The 4% rate cap on
mortgages - how it will work
It is important to
keep in mind that much of the detail of
this new legislation is going to be
provided by secondary regulations which
are still being drafted. An implementing
circular is expected from the Italian
Finance Ministry, as the benefit will be
financed by a tax credit to the
implementing banks.
However on a
practical level, the benefit will be
automatic in the sense that no
application will be required by the
taxpayers affected. Given that the
Italian tax authorities already have
full details of all taxpayers who
claimed the main residence benefit at
the time of acquisition of their
property, lists will be sent to all
Italian banks, who will select their
clients who have taken out the relevant
mortgages.
Where the Italian
banks will become aware that the benefit
applies to any of their clients, the
relevant bank will first debit the full
amount of the relevant mortgage
instalment (when actually due) and then
at the same time, will credit back any
amount of interest charged on variable
rate mortgages, in excess of 4%.
Italian banks will
then report the amounts credited back
(expected to total approximately Euro
350 million) to the Italian Revenue,
thus becoming entitled to a tax credit
for the amounts paid back.
Under current
legislation this benefit will apply for
the whole of 2009 only. Where the
benefit is delayed, the taxpayer will be
entitled to a full credit, and placed in
the same position as if he had received the
benefit from the 1st January 2009.
3)
Further protection
for Italian property owners.
The above provisions
are only part of a much wider strategy
of support for the Italian economy.
Other provisions are also likely to
benefit property owners.
-
European
Central Bank rates - Italian
banks are now legally required to offer
to borrowers mortgages directly linked
to the European Central Bank rate,
rather than as it was in the past,
linked to Euribor, the interbank rate.
The choice of course, is open to the
borrower.
This is due to the
fact that in the last few months, the
Euribor rate, which is the rate
applicable to loans between banks has
been rather volatile. Mortgages linked
to the European Central Bank rate
promise to be more stable in the
short term, even if they may not always
be less expensive. It is to be expected
that any rate reduction in the European
Central bank rate will be passed to the
borrowers far more quickly than was the
case with the Euribor mortgages.
The Bank of Italy,
the authority which has the supervision
of banks operating in Italy has also
issued regulations requiring Italian
banks to offer full information and
choice to potential borrowers, on all
the option legally available and open to
them.
-
Provisions for
the transfer of mortgages, from one bank
to another - General
provisions aimed at making it easier for
borrowers to transfer their mortgages
from one bank to another (Portabilita`
del mutuo) and thus increasing
competition between banks operating in
Italy were introduced a few years ago.
Rather surprisingly,
the new legislation now provides that
the transfer of a mortgage from one bank
to another, in Italy, is effected free
of charge. Italian notaries and Italian
banks are required to provide their
services related to the transfers of
mortgages without charging fees.
These provisions
apply where the mortgage in question was
used to finance the taxpayer’s main
residence or restore it, there are also
a number of other restrictions.
-
Bank regulation
- The same legislation declares
illegal and unenforceable some terms
usually found in the current account
documentation of banks in Italy. These
terms must now unilaterally be removed
by the banks from the contract with
their clients, within 150 days of the
new legislation coming into force.
These terms relate to
bank charges levied as a percentage of
the funds potentially made available to
clients, whether these funds / borrowing
limits are actually used / borrowed or
not (Commissione di massimo scoperto
and Provvigione di conto), or
where the funds have actually been used
for less than 30 days. Where a bank does
not comply the client can refer to the
Italian banking ombudsman (Ombudsman
Bancario) in Rome, or take the
matter to Court.
4)
The wider
picture.
The above provisions
are only a small part of a larger piece
of legislation in support of the poorer
members of society and small / medium
enterprises, whose estimated total value
is up to Euro 5 billions.
Other provisions
relate to a bonus ranging between Euro
200 and Euro 1000 to resident poorer
families, the freezing of charges,
tariffs and costs normally linked to
inflation and support for small / medium
companies.
Various other
provisions relate to other changes to
Italian taxes which will generally
support the economy at a critical time.
The writer very much hopes that these
measures will have the desired effect.